EDA criticizes traffic light labeling for “inadequate” information on dairy

aaedf6d7-8051-4c1e-9b4a-bb94c675db58articleimage.jpg

01 Dec 2017 --- The European Dairy Association (EDA) has pointed out that the EU dairy sector highlights the nutritional value of dairy and its importance in the diet – and thus does not support the proposed traffic light labeling by the six multinational food companies grouped in the Evolved Nutrition Labeling Initiative (ENL) as it is not adequate for better informing on global nutritional properties of milk and dairy products.

The ENL proposal is an extension of the color-coded UK traffic light system but with reference values including portions (and not only on 100g). “Such a scheme should look at the food as a whole and support foods rich in essential nutrients,” EDA points out in a press release.

Official protest
EDA Secretary General Alexander Anton officially protested the proposal in today’s joint meeting of the “High Level Group on Nutrition and Physical Activity” and the “EU Platform for Action on Diet, Physical Activity and Health” in Luxembourg.
 
“For the second time this year, the EU Commission offered a high-level platform to a group of six multinationals to present and hence promote their own nutrition labeling scheme,” Anton said. “I know we’re not the only ones questioning the EU Commission leaving the leadership in this dossier to national authorities or to six multinationals: basically, all these schemes may well be very sophisticated, but they’re not based on all relevant science on diets and do in no way reflect common sense.”

“Nutrition labeling schemes where a diet soft drink ranks healthier than drinking milk are obviously and seriously nonsense,” Anton added. “Nevertheless, the Luxembourg-based EU Commission services do help directly or indirectly to promote such nutrition labeling schemes.”
 
“I protested and urged the EU Commission to stop any such scheme in place like the UK traffic light [scheme] and to stop any direct or indirect support for any nutrition labeling schemes that fail what I personally call the ‘diet soft drink vs. drinking milk’ test,” concluded Anton.

The test refers to Anton’s previous statement: “There is seriously something wrong with a scheme where a diet soda drink ranks better than drinking milk.”

Nutrient issues
EDA says it supports consumers’ right to be fully informed on the nutritional properties of foods, one of the legal requirements of the Food Information to Consumers Regulation (EU) No 1169/2011. It adds that it believes that voluntary labeling schemes used in addition to the nutrition declaration required by the EU law can be a useful additional tool for consumers if they fulfill a number of important criteria.

EDA believes that a good voluntary labeling scheme should be thoroughly evaluated, have a significant positive impact on consumer behavior and public health, be compatible with EU legislation and be supported by relevant stakeholders. In the organization’s view, the latest traffic light scheme proposal by six multinational food companies grouped in the ENL does not fulfill these requirements and thus is not an adequate system for milk and dairy products.

The association notes that it is fully engaged on nutrition and health topics with policy-makers, industry groups and other stakeholders to help make a positive impact on overall public health. The health and nutrition debate has always been very close to the dairy industry, it adds: “Over the last years, the European dairy sector has put a lot of effort, research and resources to ensure that consumers have access to a wide range of nutritious dairy products.”

However, EDA warns: “The proposed system includes only the content of fat, saturated fat, sugar and salt and fully ignores any positive nutrients such as protein, vitamins and minerals.”

Selective labeling system
Such a selective approach does not recognize the importance of nutrient-dense foods as recommended in dietary recommendations nor does it help consumers to compose a balanced and varied diet with nutritious foods, according to EDA. It believes that traffic light-style schemes such as ENL are not in line with the principle of providing “objective and non-discriminatory” food information required by the EU legislation because the introduction of color-coding is a non-objective judgment of the nutritional quality of products and unnecessarily discriminate certain foods.

In addition, EDA reports that the UK traffic light system has not shown to change the consumer behavior, and no study so far proves that color-coded and “negative nutrient” based schemes indeed help to improve public health in ways like reducing obesity.

Considering other positive labeling systems, EDA notes that alternatives consider the overall nutritional quality of foods in a “more balanced” way, without “harmful discrimination of basic foods.” It believes that systems which are worth further discussion and consideration by the interested stakeholders could be the Australian Health Star Rating scheme or the Choices International logo.

Related Articles

Business News

Dynamic OTC marketplace: Albertsons and Rite Aid merge, Amazon enters the fray

21 Feb 2018 --- Albertsons Companies, one of the US’ largest grocery retailers, and leading drugstore chain Rite Aid Corporation have announced a definitive merger agreement, creating a retail behemoth with US$83 billion in annual revenue. The move is thought to give the integrated company more weight to compete with bigger chains in an industry anxious about the reported entry of Amazon.com.

Nutrition & Health News

Low-fat and low-carb diets equally effective, Stanford study finds

21 Feb 2018 --- After years of debate, a new study at the Stanford University School of Medicine has found that neither a low-fat nor a low-carb diet is superior: Cutting either carbs or fats leads to a reduction of excess weight in about the same proportion, according to the study. The study also looked into whether insulin levels or a specific genotype pattern could predict an individual's success on either diet. The answer, in both cases, was no.

Business News

Lonza to expand Florida encapsulation capabilities amid product development acceleration

21 Feb 2018 --- Swiss multinational, chemicals and biotechnology company, the Lonza Group is planning to expand its late-stage clinical and commercial encapsulation capabilities for solid oral and inhaled dosage forms in North America. The company will install a new Harro Hӧfliger Modu-C MS encapsulation unit (Harro unit) at its integrated product development and manufacturing facility in Tampa, Florida, to strengthen production and bring its products to market faster. 

Nutrition & Health News

ExcelVite palm tocotrienol complex eases severe pain, diabetic patient study reveals

20 Feb 2018 --- Researchers at the University Science of Malaysia have found that daily doses of EVNol SupraBio – a bio-enhanced full spectrum palm tocotrienol complex – can help to relieve severe pain (lancinating pain) in diabetic neuropathy patients. Focusing on diabetic neuropathy patients (DPN), this Vitamin E Neuroprotection Study (VENUS) was a randomized, double-blind clinical trial carried out to discover how to better manage the challenging issue of painful neuropathy. It is the largest tocotrienol human clinical study of its kind. 

Nutrition & Health News

Low-carb diet found to help battle fatty liver disease

20 Feb 2018 --- A carbohydrate-restricted diet can lead to “rapid and dramatic” reductions of liver fat and other cardiometabolic risk factors, along with marked decreases in the synthesis of hepatic fat, reveals a study published last week in Cell Metabolism. The study results could lead to improved treatments for non-alcoholic fatty liver disease (NAFLD). 

More Articles
URL : http://www.nutritioninsight.com:80/news/eda-criticizes-traffic-light-labeling-for-inadequate-information-on-dairy.html