EDA criticizes traffic light labeling for “inadequate” information on dairy


01 Dec 2017 --- The European Dairy Association (EDA) has pointed out that the EU dairy sector highlights the nutritional value of dairy and its importance in the diet – and thus does not support the proposed traffic light labeling by the six multinational food companies grouped in the Evolved Nutrition Labeling Initiative (ENL) as it is not adequate for better informing on global nutritional properties of milk and dairy products.

The ENL proposal is an extension of the color-coded UK traffic light system but with reference values including portions (and not only on 100g). “Such a scheme should look at the food as a whole and support foods rich in essential nutrients,” EDA points out in a press release.

Official protest
EDA Secretary General Alexander Anton officially protested the proposal in today’s joint meeting of the “High Level Group on Nutrition and Physical Activity” and the “EU Platform for Action on Diet, Physical Activity and Health” in Luxembourg.
“For the second time this year, the EU Commission offered a high-level platform to a group of six multinationals to present and hence promote their own nutrition labeling scheme,” Anton said. “I know we’re not the only ones questioning the EU Commission leaving the leadership in this dossier to national authorities or to six multinationals: basically, all these schemes may well be very sophisticated, but they’re not based on all relevant science on diets and do in no way reflect common sense.”

“Nutrition labeling schemes where a diet soft drink ranks healthier than drinking milk are obviously and seriously nonsense,” Anton added. “Nevertheless, the Luxembourg-based EU Commission services do help directly or indirectly to promote such nutrition labeling schemes.”
“I protested and urged the EU Commission to stop any such scheme in place like the UK traffic light [scheme] and to stop any direct or indirect support for any nutrition labeling schemes that fail what I personally call the ‘diet soft drink vs. drinking milk’ test,” concluded Anton.

The test refers to Anton’s previous statement: “There is seriously something wrong with a scheme where a diet soda drink ranks better than drinking milk.”

Nutrient issues
EDA says it supports consumers’ right to be fully informed on the nutritional properties of foods, one of the legal requirements of the Food Information to Consumers Regulation (EU) No 1169/2011. It adds that it believes that voluntary labeling schemes used in addition to the nutrition declaration required by the EU law can be a useful additional tool for consumers if they fulfill a number of important criteria.

EDA believes that a good voluntary labeling scheme should be thoroughly evaluated, have a significant positive impact on consumer behavior and public health, be compatible with EU legislation and be supported by relevant stakeholders. In the organization’s view, the latest traffic light scheme proposal by six multinational food companies grouped in the ENL does not fulfill these requirements and thus is not an adequate system for milk and dairy products.

The association notes that it is fully engaged on nutrition and health topics with policy-makers, industry groups and other stakeholders to help make a positive impact on overall public health. The health and nutrition debate has always been very close to the dairy industry, it adds: “Over the last years, the European dairy sector has put a lot of effort, research and resources to ensure that consumers have access to a wide range of nutritious dairy products.”

However, EDA warns: “The proposed system includes only the content of fat, saturated fat, sugar and salt and fully ignores any positive nutrients such as protein, vitamins and minerals.”

Selective labeling system
Such a selective approach does not recognize the importance of nutrient-dense foods as recommended in dietary recommendations nor does it help consumers to compose a balanced and varied diet with nutritious foods, according to EDA. It believes that traffic light-style schemes such as ENL are not in line with the principle of providing “objective and non-discriminatory” food information required by the EU legislation because the introduction of color-coding is a non-objective judgment of the nutritional quality of products and unnecessarily discriminate certain foods.

In addition, EDA reports that the UK traffic light system has not shown to change the consumer behavior, and no study so far proves that color-coded and “negative nutrient” based schemes indeed help to improve public health in ways like reducing obesity.

Considering other positive labeling systems, EDA notes that alternatives consider the overall nutritional quality of foods in a “more balanced” way, without “harmful discrimination of basic foods.” It believes that systems which are worth further discussion and consideration by the interested stakeholders could be the Australian Health Star Rating scheme or the Choices International logo.

To contact our editorial team please email us at editorial@cnsmedia.com

Related Articles

Nutrition & Health News

Nutrient breakthrough: Scientists show plants can be a dietary source of vitamin B12

24 May 2018 --- Scientists at the University of Kent have made a significant discovery about how the vitamin B12 content of some plants can be improved to make vegetarian and vegan diets more complete. Vitamin B12 (known as cobalamin) is an essential dietary component but vegans and vegetarians are more prone to B12 deficiency as plants neither make nor require this nutrient.

Nutrition & Health News

US FDA takes action against OTC benzocaine products for teething infants

24 May 2018 --- The US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) has warned that over-the-counter (OTC) teething products containing benzocaine may pose a serious risk to infants and children. The popular numbing agent can offer temporary relief to sore gums in teething infants; however, the FDA advises that companies stop marketing and selling these products for use. The agency is also raising awareness of the risks that, they state, come with other oral health benzocaine products. 

Nutrition & Health News

UK sugar reduction efforts fail to reach initial target, industry urged to step up or face tax

23 May 2018 --- The first assessment of the UK government’s sugar reduction program has unveiled failings by industry to reduce sugar in the first year by 5 percent, leading to calls of a sugar tax on sweet treats. The results of the first year have been roundly criticized in the media and described as “hugely disappointing” after Public Health England data revealed that sugar was cut in some categories – sweet spreads and sauces, yogurts and fromage frais and breakfast cereals – while other food groups have fallen short.

Nutrition & Health News

Green protein boost: INCJ and Mitsubishi Corp. invest over US$15m in microalgae protein maker

23 May 2018 --- Innovation Network Corporation of Japan (INCJ) and Mitsubishi Corp. (MC) have announced a joint investment in microalgae company Tavelmout through the acceptance of a third-party allocation of shares by Tavelmout. The total investment amounts to 1.7 billion yen (US$15.47 million), evenly split between INCJ and MC. Through their participation in Tavelmout, a company aiming to mass produce and popularize spirulina, MC and INCJ are seeking to contribute to the diversification of sustainable protein sources.

Nutrition & Health News

Diabetes UK: “Consumers want to see clearer calorie labeling on food and menus” 

23 May 2018 --- Consumers are more likely to purchase food if it is accompanied by clear calorie labels on its packaging or on the menu of the establishment, a survey conducted by Diabetes UK’s campaign, Food Upfront, has found. The survey sheds light on how the availability of clear labeling on food and drink could have considerable influence on the spending habits of the British public. Therefore, the campaign is calling for mandatory front-of-pack traffic light labeling on foods and menu calorie labeling in eating establishments.

More Articles
URL : http://www.nutritioninsight.com:80/news/eda-criticizes-traffic-light-labeling-for-inadequate-information-on-dairy.html