Cargill’s erythritol dental health claim rejected by EFSA

791f45fc-913c-4cfa-a947-038ec3c1fdb0articleimage.jpg

27 Jul 2017 --- Cargill cannot prove its EU Article 14 claim submission [disease risk reduction claim] that there is a cause-and-effect relationship between sugar-free hard confectionery with at least 90 percent erythritol and the reduction of dental plaque, according to the European Food Safety Authority (EFSA).

Cargill had applied to be able to legally make a claim on its confectionery. As a rule: “health claims are prohibited unless they comply with the general and specific requirements of Regulation (EC) No 1924/2006, which establishes rules governing the European Community authorization of health claims made on foods,” EFSA says.

Cargill wanted to make the following claim possible on confectionery products sweetened with erythritol: “Sugar-free hard confectionery sweetened with at least 90 percent Zerose erythritol has been shown to reduce dental plaque. High content/level of dental plaque is a risk factor in the development of caries.”

The company had therefore submitted a dossier to EFSA aiming to prove that the effect of erythritol: “could be explained by a reduction in dental plaque resulting from reduced growth and adherence of common streptococcal oral bacteria to tooth surfaces and reduced acid production by the bacteria.”

However, EFSA experts say they could not substantiate the claim “in the absence of evidence for an effect on the incidence of dental caries in vivo in humans.”

A large issue with the claim was the fact that Cargill did not specify which properties of Zerose erythritol sugar-free hard confectionery were “unique in relation to the claimed effect as compared to other sugar-free hard confectionery containing 90 percent erythritol.” EFSA experts, therefore, decided that Cargill could not make a claim unique to its product.

Problems with one of the studies that Cargill used were also pointed out by EFSA scientists: “In weighing the evidence, the Panel took into account that one human intervention study […] with some methodological limitations (e.g. data analysis for completers only) did not show an effect of sugar-free hard confectionery with at least 90 percent erythritol on the incidence of dental caries in children on either mixed or permanent dentition.”

The food constituent Zerose erythritol, the subject of the claim, “is a low molecular weight polyol that has zero calories and is non-glycaemic and non-insulinemic,” according to the EFSA report. “The erythritol is in the form of sugar-free hard confectionery sweetened with at least 90 percent Zerose erythritol.” 

Sugar-free hard confectionery is classified by EFSA as candies with a hard texture with no added sugar, and sugar-free hard confectionery includes hard candies, pastilles, lozenges, tablets and breath-freshening micro sweets. 

The full opinion of EFSA from its journal can be read here.

By Paul Creasy

To contact our editorial team please email us at editorial@cnsmedia.com

Cargill-Europe

Collapse

More than simply a food ingredients supplier, Cargill deeply understands our customers' strategies, consumers, distribution channels and competition. We deliver solutions that help the food industry and beverage manufacturers drive growth through new product innovation and reformulation. Cargill helps reduce costs through supply chain and manufacturing process efficiency and managing commodity price risk. Cargill helps our food industry and beverage manufacturing customers create unique products that fill product pipelines and reduce time-to-market by connecting our diverse food ingredients supplier capabilities — marketers, research scientist, application experts, risk managers and manufacturing process engineers — and seamlessly delivering these resources to customers. As a service and solution-oriented food ingredients supplier, our broad portfolio helps our customers address their food product development needs across the spectrum of applications and categories. Cargill helps our customers safely manufacture products every day around the world by reliably originating and distributing grain, oilseeds and other food ingredient commodities and by processing a diverse food ingredients supplier portfolio that spans core and specialty ingredients, ingredient systems and finished food systems.

Related Articles

Health & Nutrition News

Maple water: One to watch amid plant-based waters surge

15 Aug 2018 --- Plant-based waters are rising as a share of soft drink launches, with Innova Market Insights reporting a 25 percent CAGR in this emerging area of NPD between 2012 and 2017, compared with a 7 percent CAGR for the soft drinks category as a whole. Despite coconut water clearly leading the plant-based hydration category, 2017 saw 28 percent of the category launches from new plant-based waters, with maple water among the beverages within this category expansion, albeit from a small base.

Health & Nutrition News

Coca-Cola invests in Bodyarmor, challenges Pepsi’s sports drink dominance

15 Aug 2018 --- Coca-Cola is to acquire a minority ownership stake in Bodyarmor – a fast-growing line of premium sports performance and hydration beverages – in a move that signifies Coca-Cola’s challenge to the strong market player Gatorade, which is owned by Pepsi. Financial terms of the agreement, including the size of the acquired stake, have not been disclosed.

Health & Nutrition News

Plant-based and dairy-free: Delivering on consumer taste and texture expectations

14 Aug 2018 --- The demand for dairy-free and plant-based products is growing. However, taste continues to reign supreme as consumers want dairy-free products but without budging on flavor or texture. Such demands have led to a range of R&D moves to overcome textural, stability and flavor challenges while aiming to keep ingredient lists as short as possible. NutritionInsight speaks to suppliers on how they are responding to the ever-expanding dairy-free trend, with a focus on plant-based protein and milk options. 

Regulatory News

Pesticide Testing: NSF International updates dietary supplement certification standard

14 Aug 2018 --- NSF International and the NSF/ANSI 173 Joint Committee have updated the pesticide testing requirements included in NSF/ANSI 173, the only American National Standard for dietary supplements. A recent NSF study established chemical-specific pesticide limits for 185 pesticides that might be present in botanical ingredients used in dietary supplement ingredients.

Health & Nutrition News

Microbe colonization study could inspire better probiotics, claim researchers

13 Aug 2018 --- A novel approach to identify the genes that may be important to help microbes live successfully in the human gut has been identified by a study published in PLOS Computational Biology. The approach utilizes a technique called phylogenetic linear modeling, which has often been used in ecology, but rarely in genomics. The researchers hope that the findings could be important for the development of new therapies to maintain or improve gut health, such as the design of better probiotics.

More Articles
URL : http://www.nutritioninsight.com:80/news/cargills-erythritol-dental-health-claim-rejected-by-efsa.html