Cargill’s erythritol dental health claim rejected by EFSA

791f45fc-913c-4cfa-a947-038ec3c1fdb0articleimage.jpg

27 Jul 2017 --- Cargill cannot prove its EU Article 14 claim submission [disease risk reduction claim] that there is a cause-and-effect relationship between sugar-free hard confectionery with at least 90 percent erythritol and the reduction of dental plaque, according to the European Food Safety Authority (EFSA).

Cargill had applied to be able to legally make a claim on its confectionery. As a rule: “health claims are prohibited unless they comply with the general and specific requirements of Regulation (EC) No 1924/2006, which establishes rules governing the European Community authorization of health claims made on foods,” EFSA says.

Cargill wanted to make the following claim possible on confectionery products sweetened with erythritol: “Sugar-free hard confectionery sweetened with at least 90 percent Zerose erythritol has been shown to reduce dental plaque. High content/level of dental plaque is a risk factor in the development of caries.”

The company had therefore submitted a dossier to EFSA aiming to prove that the effect of erythritol: “could be explained by a reduction in dental plaque resulting from reduced growth and adherence of common streptococcal oral bacteria to tooth surfaces and reduced acid production by the bacteria.”

However, EFSA experts say they could not substantiate the claim “in the absence of evidence for an effect on the incidence of dental caries in vivo in humans.”

A large issue with the claim was the fact that Cargill did not specify which properties of Zerose erythritol sugar-free hard confectionery were “unique in relation to the claimed effect as compared to other sugar-free hard confectionery containing 90 percent erythritol.” EFSA experts, therefore, decided that Cargill could not make a claim unique to its product.

Problems with one of the studies that Cargill used were also pointed out by EFSA scientists: “In weighing the evidence, the Panel took into account that one human intervention study […] with some methodological limitations (e.g. data analysis for completers only) did not show an effect of sugar-free hard confectionery with at least 90 percent erythritol on the incidence of dental caries in children on either mixed or permanent dentition.”

The food constituent Zerose erythritol, the subject of the claim, “is a low molecular weight polyol that has zero calories and is non-glycaemic and non-insulinemic,” according to the EFSA report. “The erythritol is in the form of sugar-free hard confectionery sweetened with at least 90 percent Zerose erythritol.” 

Sugar-free hard confectionery is classified by EFSA as candies with a hard texture with no added sugar, and sugar-free hard confectionery includes hard candies, pastilles, lozenges, tablets and breath-freshening micro sweets. 

The full opinion of EFSA from its journal can be read here.

By Paul Creasy

Related Articles

Nutrition & Health News

Drink your vitamins: SternVitamin launches micronutrient premix for beverages 

19 Feb 2018 --- A healthy lifestyle is essential to all age groups, and nutrition plays a major role alongside various other components. SternVitamin is now offering beverage manufacturers a novel way to address the topic of health with a new micronutrient premix for healthy bones and heart. SternVitamin notes that the mix picks up on one of the top trends in the beverage market – water-based enriched products. The vegan premix contains vitamins B1, B12, C, K2 and D3. Organic agave syrup powder gives it a slight sweetness, while natural flavors give the drink a “dark berry” taste. It dissolves clear in water and leaves no turbidity. 

Nutrition & Health News

“Unhelpful”: EU regulatory framework fuels nutrition industry dissatisfaction 

16 Feb 2018 --- A survey reveals that one-third of all nutrition industry professionals believe that the current EU framework for achieving a health claim on new products is stunting innovation because it’s complicated, expensive, long-winded and has several “gray areas.” And “regulation frustration” is a strong feeling running through the industry with many more professionals now believing the current EU regulatory environment is “unhelpful” – a 25 percent hike compared with statistics from the beginning of 2017. Experts are attributing this sharp rise in dissatisfaction to the EU’s tough stance on health claims and the current regulatory deadlock on botanicals.

Nutrition & Health News

Façade? British Nutrition Foundation questions benefit of skin beauty nutraceuticals

14 Feb 2018 --- Although there is a growing market for orally consumed beauty supplements that promise “youthful,” “firm” and “glowing” skin, the evidence to support some of the ingredients used in these popular, and often costly, products is limited. This is according to a review of published research conducted by the British Nutrition Foundation (BNF). The review concludes that nutraceuticals for skin may not add further benefit to the effects already obtained from a healthy diet. 

Nutrition & Health News

Clear definition and regulations needed to tap into nutraceuticals’ potential: review

13 Feb 2018 --- Nutraceuticals with health benefits substantiated by clinical data can be powerful tools to prevent and treat medical conditions, especially in individuals who may not yet be eligible for conventional pharmaceutical drugs. However, there is a clear need for clear regulations to ensure their safety. This is according to a review published in the British Journal of Clinical Pharmacology, which further proposes a clear definition for this type of product. 

Business News

AI and personalized nutrition: Nestlé and Nuritas partner on bioactive peptide development

09 Feb 2018 --- Nestlé and biotech company Nuritas have entered into a collaboration aiming to uncover bioactive peptide networks within “specific target areas of significant value.” The precise areas of investigation are not yet being shared, with Nuritas Commercial Manager Neil Foster telling NutritionInsight that these details and the expected launch date are “at this early stage understandably confidential.” As part of the collaboration, Nuritas is to deploy its novel technology platform, which uses Artificial Intelligence and DNA analysis to predict, unlock and validate highly efficacious peptides, exclusively from natural food sources. Nestlé will use their considerable scientific know-how and applications expertise to validate the efficacy of these discoveries within the target applications.

More Articles
URL : http://www.nutritioninsight.com:80/news/cargills-erythritol-dental-health-claim-rejected-by-efsa.html